| Ken Bierschbach | vocals, guitar, bass | The Christmas Song |
| vocals, guitar, bass | What Christmas Means to Me | |
| background vocals, shakers | Away in a Manger | |
| J. Oscar Bittinger | vocals, guitar | A Winter’s Tune |
| vocals, guitar | Angels We Have Heard on High | |
| Lauran Bittinger | harmony vocals, accordian | A Winter’s Tune |
| harmony vocals | Angels We Have Heard on High | |
| Leo Contrera | chromatic harmonica | Little Drummer Boy |
| Chris Douglas | lead guitar | Wind and Snow |
| Mark DePree | vocals, guitar | Wind and Snow |
| vocals, acoustic & slide guitars | Silent Night | |
| background vocals | Away in a Manger | |
| bass | Our Finest Year | |
| Dave Molinari | vocals, guitar | Rise Up, Shepherd, and Follow |
| vocals, piano | Christmas Eve | |
| snare drum | What Christmas Means to Me | |
| Drew Nelson | vocals, guitar | Baby for a King |
| vocals, guitar | Hark, the Herald Angels Sing | |
| background vocals | Light a Candle | |
| Ralston | vocals, guitar | Light a Candle |
| vocals, guitar | Little Drummer Boy | |
| Sara Q | vocals, guitar | Our Finest Year |
| vocals, guitars | I’m Gettin’ Nuttin’ for Christmas | |
| Ric Troll | hand percussion | Little Drummer Boy |
| Lucy Webster | guitar, vocals | Away in a Manger |
| guitar | Falling Snow | |
| Andy Willey | vocals, guitar | The Spirit of Christmas |
| vocals, guitar | O Holy Night | |
| background vocals | Away in a Manger | |
| Leah Willey | harmony vocals | The Spirit of Christmas |
| Norm Williams | background vocals | Away in a Manger |